I wanted to say I was incredibly disappointed in your broadcast
today. You were obviously far to uneducated on the subject to make
any valid points regarding the dairy industry and migrant/seasonal labor in
Iowa. It quickly became evident that your agenda was to knock congressman
Braley, when in reality you were the one that has not educated yourself enough
on the topic to adequately contradict anything he stated. The fact is, and
one of the final callers pointed this out, that often times the AMERICAN Farm
Bureau organization has very different political objectives than the Iowa
chapter of Farm Bureau. The fact you didn't know there was a difference
was quite disappointing. On a national level, migrant/seasonal labor is a
much larger issue than right here in Iowa. Congressman Braley was just
trying to illustrate how the national organizations goals may apply here in
Iowa. The Market to Market show last Sunday on IPTV ran a good story
showcasing just how big of an issue it is. They interviewed several
farmers in California who depend on nearly 100% migrant labor to grow and
harvest their crop. Also, by constantly referring to them as
"cheap" labor is another instance proving your lack of knowledge on
the topic. It is absolutely fact that a high percentage of migrant
workers earn well above the federal minimum wage.
Also, the fact that you couldn't understand why the dairy industry can't
produce their product and provide the same level of service as it did decades
ago (home delivery) showed me just how out of touch with the agricultural
industry you really are (which is quite concerning since you make a living
offering opinions on such things in an ag dominated state). One caller
did a pretty good job of pointing out that the rise in retail cost of
their product has significantly lagged behind the rise in cost of
production. The sad reality is that, much like yourself, the American
people have no idea what it costs to produce a gallon of milk, and have decided
they are not willing pay over $3 or $4 per gallon (such is the case with many,
many American made products, not just milk).
I certainly don't always agree with your opinions, but you typically prove to
have educated yourself enough on the subject to have developed a valid
opinion. Today you showed me that you let partisan politics significantly
influence your show, instead of the facts. Please go back to doing your
homework and make this a 1 time fluke of a show. Just because it’s a
Democrat politician making a statement, does not immediately make it false.
It usually does… especially Braley… he’s the guy who knowing violates the Constitution by using blackmail to accomplish an issue for which there is no federal jurisdiction…Kadyn's Law... he’s now pushing school based radon testing…..another non-issue at the federal level… Braley has a pattern of expanding federal authority and spending on ssues which should be done at the state level. Now he wants an amnesty for people who have busted the border. You just demonstrated that the whole agri-business political mix is so convoluted and rife with cost shifting the public is clueless about how many ways they are being shafted. Conversations like these are very usefu in demonstrating the corruption of the system. Importing people whose productivity doesn’t off-set the costs of their presence is stupid….worse is destructive to our culture. If the US can’t produce milk at a profit to the farmers without vast subsidies and mported labor, then milk may be a commodity which shouldn’t be on the shelves. If demand has fallen to the point where profit isn’tpossible, or supply exceeds demand, then politics isn’t the solution. I’d use the same principle for any commodity. By the way, I’m still waiting for the Iowa Farm Bureau to issue a press release repudiating the American Farm Bureau position. When it does, you may have a valid point. And California is a real piece of work. Several years ago, California taxpayers ponied up millions of dollars to buy out California dairy farmers in order to reduce supply and cut subsidies. California dairy farmers used the money to buy more real estate, build fancy houses in the middle of feed lots, and wait out the moratorium. Then they went right back in business with bigger units and a better house….right back on the public teat.
Yah, this is a big issue with many inter-related issues. But it isn’t that mysterious. As long as everyone is willing to live at the expense of others we’ll have a problem. BTW… it is cheap labor…. Iowa is a cheap labor state. As I’ve often reported, my dad and I both
worked in the processing industry in the late 60’s….. we made twice what
these workers are getting now. Now the industry passes on the real production costs to the tax payers. Our welfare state mentality has almost destroyed us….whether we’re talking about making babies or growing milk. Government has distorted the market for both.